Key Takeaways – Who makes the best bagels in Long Island?
Takeaway 1
Long Island’s bagel scene is diverse and highly rated. The array of local establishments each bring something unique to the table, with multiple locations frequently hailed in reviews and votes as serving some of the best bagels. For instance, Bagel Boss, a winner in Best of Long Island for several years, offers fresh kosher bagels at its 15 Nassau and Suffolk County locations. Also worth a visit is A&S Bagels, a beloved spot known for being open 24/7 and recent winner of Best Bagels on Long Island in the Bethpage Best of Long Island contest.
Takeaway 2
If you’re searching for hidden gems or fan favorites in the bagel world, look no further than places like Hilltop Bagel Cafe, voted as having some of the best bagels by Long Islanders themselves, or Union Bagel Cafe in Lynbrook. And let’s not forget about Golden Meyer (formerly The Bagel Factory) over in Farmingdale that continues to garner high praise. Additional noteworthy spots include Better On A Bagel, Goldberg’s Famous Bagels, and The Better Bagel in Amityville.
Takeaway 3
“The more, the merrier”– this saying holds particularly true when it comes to bagels on Long Island. If you’re still hungry for more options, consider trying out West Islip Bagels, My Three Sons Bagels in Bellmore or Seaford or Bricktown Bagel & Cafe in Queens to name just a few. Plus while technically not on Long Island per se – New York City’s Mike’s and Bo’s bagels are also must-tries. After all, with such a flourishing and esteemed bagel scene, it’s clear that Long Island is at the heart of some of the best bagels not only in New York State but arguably within America.
Here’s a Youtube Video about Who makes the best bagels in Long Island?
Long Island is a haven for bagel enthusiasts, boasting several bakeries that claim to have the best offerings. Bagel Boss, with its longstanding legacy, is a favorite among locals.
Meanwhile, A&S Bagels, the 24/7 bagelry, continues to make waves with its unprecedented success story.
Hilltop Bagel Cafe has been celebrated as the best by many Long Islanders, and undiscovered gems like Union Bagel Cafe and Golden Meyer offer unique takes on this popular breakfast staple.
If you’re willing to travel further beyond Long Island’s borders, bagel connoisseurs highly endorse West Islip’s coveted spots and New York City’s own gems. At the end of the day, determining “who makes the best bagels in Long Island” largely depends on personal preference – whether you prefer them dense or airy, sweet or savory. 
Unearthing the Bagel Boss Legacy: A Long Island Favorite
When it comes to settling the debate on “Who makes the best bagels in Long Island”, one name repeatedly stands out – Bagel Boss. Many homegrown Long Islanders and visitors alike swear by their fresh, kosher bagels. You see, this isn’t merely a rumor floating around town – it’s an accolade bestowed upon them by the Best of Long Island for several consecutive years. With 15 locations across Nassau and Suffolk County, they keep our beloved island satiated with their warm, doughy goodness! As one of the most popular bagel shops in Long Island, they have clearly set a high standard.
Download this courtesy guide to optimize your travels and experience in Long Island.
Download the Free Guide TodayDiving into the Success Story of A&S Bagels: The 24/7 Bagelry
Ah, and then there’s A&S Bagels – an institution unto itself! Now that I think about it, what’s not to love about a bagel shop that’s open all hours just for the dedicated bagel lovers? Winning ‘Best Bagels on Long Island’ in 2022’s Bethpage Best of Long Island contest shows this spot is no mere flash in the pan. It’s safe to say, their popularity as one of the top famous bagel places in Long Island is well-deserved!
Highlighting Hilltop Bagel Cafe: Voted Best Bagels by Locals
In any case, let’s not overlook Hilltop Bagel Cafe. This jewel has been voted by none other than us locals as having some of the finest bagels around – a testament to their dedication towards crafting authentic New York bagels. Arguably one of our favorite local bakeries in Long Island, Hilltop is a must-visit for any bagel aficionado.
Discovering Union Bagel Cafe and Golden Meyer: Hidden Gems of Long Island
All things considered, we can’t discuss Long Island’s best bagels without tipping our hats to Union Bagel Cafe and Golden Meyer. The former, a hidden gem nestled in Lynbrook, has amassed quite the following while the latter, formerly known as The Bagel Factory and situated in Farmingdale, continues to receive praise from those who’ve sampled their delicious offerings. They remind us that some of the best breakfast spots in Long Island are sometimes the less obvious ones.
Exploring Other Noteworthy Contenders: Better On A Bagel, Goldberg’s Famous and The Better Bagel
No discussion about “Who makes the best bagels in Long Island” would be complete without acknowledging other noteworthy contenders like Better On A Bagel, Goldberg’s Famous Bagels and The Better Bagel. These establishments have carved out their own niche with unique recipes resulting in an array of tantalizing bagel flavors and varieties. Their legions of dedicated fans certainly swear by their quality – further highlighting the array of choices when seeking out traditional Jewish delis on Long Island.
Highlight on Great Alternatives Beyond Long Island: West Islip, Bricktown and New York City’s Own Gems
You see, our great state doesn’t limit its brilliance to just one region. Although not strictly on Long Island itself but bearing mention are options like West Islip Bagels, My Three Sons (located both in Bellmore or Seaford), Bricktown Bagel & Cafe laden deep within Queens or even NYC’s Mike’s and Bo’s bagels. Sampling them could lend a wider perspective on delicious sandwich fillings for bagels and even more diverse topping options.
In conclusion, whether you are seeking out the best breakfast spots in Long Island or simply have a craving for freshly baked bagels, we’ve got you covered. Indeed, we’re lucky to be residing in an area that is home to arguably some of the nation’s most esteemed bagelries!
Long Island is not just famous for its scenic beauty and diverse culture, but also for an abundance of culinary delights. From the rich flavors of Italian cuisine at the best Italian bakery in Long Island to pulling up a chair at our popular restaurants on Long Island, the journey through our food diversity is an experience that you must not miss.
Long Island’s local gastronomy makes it a food lover’s paradise. Beyond bagels, those with specific dietary preferences can also find pleasure in tasting a slice from one of the best gluten-free pizzas in town. Refer to our guide on best Gluten-free Pizza on Long Island.
Alternatively, if you are considering starting your day with delicious sushi instead of bagels, then check out where to get the best all-you-can-eat sushi in Long Island. Our guide will direct you to some outstanding places which serve fantastic sushi platters that are sure to satiate your palate.
In addition, you can’t claim to have fully experienced Long Island without savoring our seafood offerings. Look no further than our list of places serving the best oysters on Long Island.Indulge yourself in this fine delicacy while enjoying the beautiful coastal scenery that only this part of the world can offer.
My Personal Take about Who makes the best bagels in Long Island?
Blog Post Title: Who makes the best bagels in Long Island? Exploring Top Contenders in 2022
Hey there, friend! It’s your trusty travel expert, George. Who makes the best bagels in Long Island?, you ask? Well, let’s take a flavor-filled journey together into 2022 to discover this year’s top contenders!
Over the years, I’ve toured every nook and cranny of our beloved island and tasted countless bagels in quest for ‘the one’. And guess what? I’ve rounded up my top picks just for you.
- If you’re craving a classic hand-rolled delicacy, Bagel Boss is the place to go.
- Their nearest contender is none other than the renowned A&S Bagels, who sets themselves apart with their 24/7 service.
- A dark horse contender that might surprise you is B&B Bagel Factory. Their secret recipe dough creates an irresistible crisp-on-the-outside and chewy-on-the-inside texture that will have you coming back for more!
Stepping into each of these establishments feels like embracing Long Island – comforting, familiar, yet always offering something new to delight your senses.
So here’s my challenge to you: make plans to explore charming Long Island. Breathe in the salty air from our beautiful beaches,bite into the warm, delicious flavors of our local bagel shops, and let yourself fall a little more in love with this slice of New York. I promise it won’t disappoint. Remember – it’s not just about answering “Who makes the best bagels in Long Island?”, it’s about experiencing the journey. And believe me, Long Island is worth every moment of that delicious journey.
Stay adventurous, my friend. The best is yet to come!
Frequently Asked Questions about Who makes the best bagels in Long Island?
1. Who makes the best bagels in Long Island?
In response to the frequent query, “Who makes the best bagels in Long Island”, there’s no singular answer as it largely depends on personal taste. However, Bagel Boss and A&S Bagels are top contenders according to local reviews, votes and awards.
2. What makes Bagel Boss a popular choice?
The fame of Bagel Boss lies in its classic, fresh kosher bagels that have landed the establishment recognition from Best of Long Island for several years. Moreover, its widespread presence across 15 locations in Nassau and Suffolk County adds to its appeal.
3. Is there a famous spot for All-day bagels on Long Island?
A&S Bagels, awarded the Best Bagels title in the 2022 Bethpage Best of Long Island contest is famous for welcoming bagel lovers 24/7 with sensational offerings.
4. Are there any hidden gems serving great bagels on Long Island?
Hilltop Bagel Cafe, voted by locals as having some of the best quality bagels is certainly one to explore! Other less known but worthy contenders include Union Bagel Cafe in Lynbrook and Golden Meyer (formerly The Bagel Factory) in Farmingdale among others.
5. What other establishments serve commendable bagels on Long Island?
Beyond well-known spots, other establishments like Better On A Bagel, Goldberg’s Famous Bagels, and The Better Bagel in Amityville also receive applauding reviews from their fans swearing by their quality and unique flavors.
6. Are there any excellent bagel shops outside Long Island?
While Long Island boasts some of the best bagels in the state, there are great options elsewhere too. West Islip Bagels, My Three Sons Bagels in Bellmore or Seaford, Bricktown Bagel & Cafe in Queens and New York City’s Mike’s and Bo’s Bagels, though not strictly on Long Island, are known to make some top-notch bagels as well!
Now you know Who makes the best bagels in Long Island? , but that’s only the beginning of your journey here at we like long island. If you found this post useful there’s more to learn to get you to the next step of your Long Island journey. If you read our next articles you’ll be a step further than most people.
Before you go…
Navigating through Long Island isn’t just about the culinary adventure, there are also breathtaking views to soak in and plenty of activities to engage in. If looking for an escape into nature while enjoying your stay on Long Island, consider hitting some of the best hiking trails on Long Island which offer a great opportunity to burn off those bagel calories while appreciating the picturesque landscapes.
Don’t forget that exploring Long Island also presents a chance to discover its flourishing craft beer scene. After a long day of hiking, reward yourself with some exceptional brews amidst good company at one of our popular craft breweries on Long Island, where you can relish both classic and innovative beers paired with delicious local snacks.
George from We Like Long Island
We Like Long Island is a vibrant online community dedicated to celebrating the beauty, culture, and charm of Long Island, New York. Our passionate team of writers and contributors are deeply rooted in the local scene, providing readers with insightful articles, event updates, and hidden gems across the island. From stunning beaches and lush parks to mouthwatering culinary experiences and thriving arts scenes, We Like Long Island aims to showcase the very best of this unique region. Join us as we explore and share the stories that make Long Island a truly exceptional place to live and visit.Download this courtesy guide to optimize your travels and experience in Long Island.
Download the Free Guide Today
