Frequently Asked Questions about Long Islands Top Oyster Bars
1. What are some top-rated oyster bars in Long Island?
In the vibrant culinary scene of Long Island, you’ll find several outstanding oyster bars. Among them, Catch Oyster Bar, South Ocean Grill, and The Monster Crab stand out for their quality and freshness. Additionally, the celebrated Salt & Barrel was crowned the Best Oyster Bar on Long Island in a 2021 contest.
2. Which establishments won recent awards for the best oyster bars on Long Island?
In addition to Salt & Barrel’s 2021 triumph, another noteworthy accolade is that of Waterzooi, which clinched the title of best oyster bar on Long Island in a 2023 contest.
3. Are there raw bars in Long Island that serve shellfish including oysters?
Absolutely! If you’re yearning for a variety of shellfish delicacies including clams and oysters, places like Anchor Down and Jeremy’s Ale House are worth exploring.
4. Which seafood restaurants serve excellent dishes besides just oysters?
In addition to stellar oyster offerings, some spots such asLouie’s Oyster Bar and Grille, E.B Elliot’s, and the riverside dine-in experience at Orient by the Sea Restaurant
.
5. Where can I get fresh raw oysters right from growers on Long Island?
You can have a first-hand experience with growers at farms like Blue Island Oysters, Great Gun, Little Ram Oysters where you can sample raw oysters straight from the source.
6. Are there any mobile options for oyster lovers in Long Island?
For sure! The Oyster Lover food truck is a unique experience that sources its fresh oysters from local aquafarms across Long Island. It’s a convenient and fun way to enjoy your favorite bivalve goodness.
Now you know Long Islands Top Oyster Bars , but that’s only the beginning of your journey here at we like long island. If you found this post useful there’s more to learn to get you to the next step of your Long Island journey. If you read our next articles you’ll be a step further than most people.
Before you go…
After gorging on succulent seafood at Long Island’s top oyster bars, you might be interested in discovering more about the local cuisine. The best gluten-free bakeries in Long Island offer a scrumptious range of pastries and desserts that are sure to satisfy your sweet tooth. From freshly baked bread to decadent cakes and cookies, these bakeries take pride in offering tasty treats that cater to all dietary preferences.
If you’re a history buff with an interest in maritime culture, Long Island’s maritime history includes fascinating insights into its rich oyster farming heritage. Many of the top oyster bars on the island owe their success to this longstanding tradition of harvesting world-class mollusks from local waters. This storied past is steeped in tales of resilience and innovation, a testament to the spirit of Long Islanders and their enduring love for high-quality seafood.
Key Takeaways – Long Islands Top Oyster Bars
Takeaway 1
Plentiful Options and Acclaim Long Island, NY, is home to a smorgasbord of top-rated oyster bars with options like Catch Oyster Bar, South Ocean Grill, Little Creek Oyster Farm & Market, and The Monster Crab, you’re never going to run out of fresh oysters. Let’s not forget about the popular Salt & Barrel, which bagged the title of Best Oyster Bar on Long Island in the 2021 Bethpage Best of Long Island contest. Incredible right?
Takeaway 2
Variety and Locality Whether you love raw bars or seafood restaurants aside from oysters, Long Island got you covered. There are places like Anchor Down, Jeremy’s Ale House serving up shellfish varieties or Louie’s Oyster Bar and Grille offering an array of seafood dishes. For those craving for that farm-to-table experience, there are farms such as Blue Island Oysters, Great Gun, or Little Ram Oysters.. Fancy mobile dining? Then The Oyster Lover food truck is for you! It sources its fresh oysters from local aquafarms across the island.
Takeaway 3
The Cream of the Crop: The Mermaid Inn Finally – let’s talk about The Mermaid Inn.. It consistently tops any list for best places for oysters in Long Island City. These eateries provide varied shellfish cuisines catering to every taste palate making them go-to spots when hunting down top-notch oyster bars on Long Island. The bottom line? Whether your preference is a sit-down or on-the-go oyster experience, Long Island will never disappoint.
Here’s a Youtube Video about Long Islands Top Oyster Bars
“Long Island’s top oyster bars” feature an impressive variety of fresh oysters and other shellfish delicacies.
From popular hotspots like Catch Oyster Bar and South Ocean Grill, to hidden gems like Little Creek Oyster Farm & Market and The Monster Crab, seafood lovers are spoilt for choice.
Not to mention, the award-winning locales such as Salt & Barrel and Waterzooi, regularly voted as the best oyster bars on Long Island, boasting an exceptional seafood menu.
Places like Louie’s Oyster Bar and Grille, Mill Pond House, E.B. Elliot’s, offers a comprehensive seafood experience, while places like Blue Island Oysters, Great Gun, and Little Ram Farms treat diners with their unique fresh raw oysters. For those always on-the-go, The Oyster Lover Food Truck makes it easy to enjoy fresh locally sourced shellfish anytime. Last but not least,The Mermaid Inn , a staple in Long Island City ‘s top-rated places for oysters. Every single establishment provides a unique dining experience sure to satisfy every shellfish enthusiast. 
Download this courtesy guide to optimize your travels and experience in Long Island.
Download the Free Guide TodayWelcome to Long Island, the Oyster Lover’s Paradise!
Have you ever laid eyes on a platter of freshly shucked oysters, glistening and inviting, promising a rush of oceanic flavors with each bite? If that’s your idea of culinary nirvana, you’d be thrilled to know that Long Island is teeming with some of the top-rated oyster bars. From Catch Oyster Bar and South Ocean Grill to The Mermaid Inn in Long Island City – they all offer irresistible seafood charms. So buckle up as I take you through an epicurean journey touching upon my favorite spots – or rather The spots for everyone who loves their shellfish.
Exploring Catch Oyster Bar and South Ocean Grill: Popular Choices for Oyster Lovers
Begin your expedition at the very popular Catch Oyster Bar. As one of Long Island’s prime oyster bars, it offers an assortment that leaves even seasoned foodies amazed. Moving on from that striking experience, we head towards South Ocean Grill. A gem amongst seafood restaurants taking pride in its fresh and delicious offerings.
Digging into Little Creek Oyster Farm & Market and The Monster Crab: A Treasure Trove of Shellfish Delicacies
In any case, if you have a growing appetite for more variety, let me introduce you to Little Creek Oyster Farm & Market and The Monster Crab. Both are conspicuous by their commitment to serve not just oysters but a whole range of shellfish delicacies.
Hightlights of Salt & Barrel and Waterzooi: Voted Best Oyster Bars on Long Island
All things considered, it’s hard not to mention Salt & Barrel and Waterzooi. These culinary stars have in fact been voted the Best Oyster Bars on Long Island. Salt & Barrel’s win in the 2021 Bethpage Best of Long Island contest, and Waterzooi’s triumph in 2023 contest are testaments to their exceptional oyster offerings.
Diving into Seafood Variety at Louie’s Oyster Bar and Grille, Mill Pond House, E.B. Elliot’s
Now that I think about it, I must also highlight eateries that go beyond oysters – like Louie’s Oyster Bar and Grille, Mill Pond House, and E.B. Elliot’s. They are paragons of exquisite seafood variety where you can tuck into a host of sumptuous dishes besides just oysters.
The Unique Experience of Fresh Raw Oysters at Blue Island Oysters, Great Gun, Little Ram Farms
You see, for those who prefer their oysters raw and unadorned, straight from the sea – there are several farms to explore. Blue Island Oysters, Great Gun, Little Ram Farms offer you the privilege to savor raw oysters right from the growers.
On-the-Go with The Oyster Lover Food Truck: Mobile Access to Fresh Locally Sourced Shellfish
In case you’re someone who appreciates mobility in dining experiences then The Oyster Lover Food Truck is definitely your kinda place! Equipped with fresh shellfish sourced from local aquafarms across Long Island, this food truck is a roving delight for all shellfish fans.
The Mermaid Inn: A Staple in Long Island City’s Top-Rated Places for Oysters
Lastly but certainly not least, I’d recommend The Mermaid Inn. A consistent frontrunner in any list of best places for oysters, it offers nothing short of a memorable dining experience in the heart of Long Island City.
By the way, these eateries, with their unique shellfish cuisines and diverse culinary experiences, have rightfully earned their spots as the go-to destinations when seeking top-notch oyster bars on Long Island. So if you are an ardent seafood lover or an adventurous foodie looking to explore unique flavors, you know where to start. Now all that is left for you to do is commence your gastronomic journey. Bon appétit!
Food and seafood lovers could not resist the allure of both the popular restaurants on Long Island and the best waterfront restaurants on Long Island that offer some of the most delicious, mouth-watering oysters. These eateries feature both local and imported varieties, satisfying every palette with their fresh, briny flavors.
For those who are fond of catching their own seafood rather than dining out, they frequently question when is the best time to go crabbing on Long Island. Similar to crabbing, timing is crucial when it comes to harvesting oysters. The same waters that are perfect for crabs are often home to some of the best oyster beds on the East Coast.
While on your quest for superb oysters, don’t forget to explore other culinary delights in the area. All you can eat sushi in Long Island is another great option for seafood enthusiasts. Japanese cuisine and raw bars go hand-in-hand with fresh oysters – a foodie’s delight indeed!
Finally, after satisfying your craving for delectable seafood at one of Long Island’s top oyster bars, why not unwind by exploring some of its natural beauty? Whether you’re a nature lover or just seeking a bit of peace after an indulgent meal, checking out the best free beaches in Long Island can be a delightful way to wrap up your day. Some of these beaches are even steps away from top-rated oyster bars, making for a truly unforgettable Long Island experience.
My Personal Take about Long Islands Top Oyster Bars
Long Islands Top Oyster Bars: A Guide to the Most Exclusive Spots
Hey there, dear reader! It’s your friend George here, coming at you with the latest and greatest from Long Island’s top oyster bars. If you know me well, you don’t need reminding that I’m a nut for everything Long Island – its beaches, its wineries, and especially its delectable seafood.
So buckle up as I take you on a mouthwatering tour of some exclusive spots where oysters rule the roost.
First stop on our list is Oyster Ponds Bistro. Nestled in Orient village, their fresh harvest will make your heart skip a beat. Next up is Billy’s By The Bay, right in Greenport – they serve ’em exactly how you like ’em with that exquisite waterfront view.
- Oyster Ponds Bistro.
- Billy’s By The Bay.
I hope this delicious journey through Long Island’s top oyster bars has left your taste buds tingling & given you an ever-increasing desire to explore our luscious island. Trust me; these experiences are nothing short of magic. And who knows? After a trip or two down here, maybe you’ll become an expert too! Bon Voyage!.
Frequently Asked Questions about Long Islands Top Oyster Bars
1. What are some top-rated oyster bars in Long Island?
In the vibrant culinary scene of Long Island, you’ll find several outstanding oyster bars. Among them, Catch Oyster Bar, South Ocean Grill, and The Monster Crab stand out for their quality and freshness. Additionally, the celebrated Salt & Barrel was crowned the Best Oyster Bar on Long Island in a 2021 contest.
2. Which establishments won recent awards for the best oyster bars on Long Island?
In addition to Salt & Barrel’s 2021 triumph, another noteworthy accolade is that of Waterzooi, which clinched the title of best oyster bar on Long Island in a 2023 contest.
3. Are there raw bars in Long Island that serve shellfish including oysters?
Absolutely! If you’re yearning for a variety of shellfish delicacies including clams and oysters, places like Anchor Down and Jeremy’s Ale House are worth exploring.
4. Which seafood restaurants serve excellent dishes besides just oysters?
In addition to stellar oyster offerings, some spots such asLouie’s Oyster Bar and Grille, E.B Elliot’s, and the riverside dine-in experience at Orient by the Sea Restaurant
.
5. Where can I get fresh raw oysters right from growers on Long Island?
You can have a first-hand experience with growers at farms like Blue Island Oysters, Great Gun, Little Ram Oysters where you can sample raw oysters straight from the source.
6. Are there any mobile options for oyster lovers in Long Island?
For sure! The Oyster Lover food truck is a unique experience that sources its fresh oysters from local aquafarms across Long Island. It’s a convenient and fun way to enjoy your favorite bivalve goodness.
Now you know Long Islands Top Oyster Bars , but that’s only the beginning of your journey here at we like long island. If you found this post useful there’s more to learn to get you to the next step of your Long Island journey. If you read our next articles you’ll be a step further than most people.
Before you go…
After gorging on succulent seafood at Long Island’s top oyster bars, you might be interested in discovering more about the local cuisine. The best gluten-free bakeries in Long Island offer a scrumptious range of pastries and desserts that are sure to satisfy your sweet tooth. From freshly baked bread to decadent cakes and cookies, these bakeries take pride in offering tasty treats that cater to all dietary preferences.
If you’re a history buff with an interest in maritime culture, Long Island’s maritime history includes fascinating insights into its rich oyster farming heritage. Many of the top oyster bars on the island owe their success to this longstanding tradition of harvesting world-class mollusks from local waters. This storied past is steeped in tales of resilience and innovation, a testament to the spirit of Long Islanders and their enduring love for high-quality seafood.
George from We Like Long Island
We Like Long Island is a vibrant online community dedicated to celebrating the beauty, culture, and charm of Long Island, New York. Our passionate team of writers and contributors are deeply rooted in the local scene, providing readers with insightful articles, event updates, and hidden gems across the island. From stunning beaches and lush parks to mouthwatering culinary experiences and thriving arts scenes, We Like Long Island aims to showcase the very best of this unique region. Join us as we explore and share the stories that make Long Island a truly exceptional place to live and visit.Download this courtesy guide to optimize your travels and experience in Long Island.
Download the Free Guide Today
