Best Pasta Long Island: Discover the Top Italian Restaurants on This East Coast Paradise

By George from We Like Long Island •  Updated: 10/10/23 •  10 min read

Sharing is caring!


Here’s a Youtube Video about Best Pasta Long Island


Welcome to the world of pasta paradise in Long Island. From Joanina Restaurant’s uniquely scrumptious pasta menu, Crabtrees’ foretaste of pasta delicacies, to Verona’s adored pasta dishes which have both locals and visitors swooning.

We aren’t stopping there. Join us as we unveil the specialties at Edoardo’s Trattoria and Nunzi’s, get a taste of Italy at The Farm Italy and il Piccolo Villaggio Ristorante, plus experience an authentic Italian cuisine at Medford Pastaria and La Margherita.

Our journey takes us further into the inviting varieties Manetta’s, Vincent’s Clam Bar, Luce Ristorante, and Cirella’s offer. Celebrate the best homemade pasta on Long Island at “La Gustosa Ravioli” before savoring an exquisite four-course Italian Meal at 18 Bay Restaurant.

Unfold Cafe Baci’s impressive pasta offerings next. But wait – there are crowd favorites too: al di la Trattoria, Lilia, Maialino.

Lastly don’t miss out on a unique fusion experience at Basta where Japanese meets Italian for an unexpected culinary twist.

In essence: if you’re searching for the best pasta in Long Island, then you’ve landed at quite the right spot.

best pasta long island
Courtesy of @ 

best pasta long island

Exploring the Pasta Menu at Joanina Restaurant

When it comes to the best pasta Long Island has to offer, my mind instantly wanders to Joanina Restaurant. This top-rated Italian restaurant offers an exquisite pasta menu that will simply leave you craving for more. Each dish is a testament to the culinary prowess of their chefs, and I can’t help but recommend this place.

The Pasta Delicacies at Crabtrees Restaurant

Moving on from Joanina, Crabtrees Restaurant, another exceptional place known for its great pasta dishes, is next on our Long Island pasta exploration. The delicious variety here certainly secures its spot in our list of top places for pasta. In any case, their rich and creamy sauces combined with perfectly cooked pasta are enough to satisfy any palate.

Why Locals and Visitors Love Verona for its Pasta

You see, one cannot talk about the best places for pasta in Long Island without mentioning the popular spot – Verona. Loved by locals and visitors alike, Verona offers a delightful range of authentic Italian pastas that are sure to tantalize your taste buds.

Unveiling the Pasta Specialties at Edoardo’s Trattoria and Nunzi’s

All things considered, when it comes to delectable varieties of pasta near Long Island, New York – Edoardo’s Trattoria and Nunzi’s are definitely worth checking out. These restaurants serve consistently impressive dishes that will take your love for pasta up several notches!

 

best pasta long island

A Taste of Italy at The Farm Italy and il Piccolo Villaggio Ristorante

Fancy a taste of Italy? Then look no further than The Farm Italy and il Piccolo Villaggio Ristorante. Both these places are highly-rated and offer delightful pasta dishes that masterfully capture the essence of Italian cuisine.

Experiencing Authentic Italian Cuisine at Medford Pastaria and La Margherita

Now that I think about it, Medford Pastaria and La Margherita deserve a special mention too. They’ve also made it to the top 10 list for their exceptional pastas. These places truly afford an opportunity to experience authentic Italian cuisine in its full glory right here on Long Island.

Diving into the Pasta Varieties at Manetta’s, Vincent’s Clam Bar, Luce Ristorante, and Cirella’s

If you’re still yearning for more pasta options, then surely Manetta’s in Long Island City, Vincent’s Clam Bar in Carle Place, Luce Ristorante in East Norwich, and Cirella’s in Melville should be your next stop. These are some of the best Italian restaurants on Long Island known for their delicious cuisine including a wide variety of pasta dishes.

Celebrating “La Gustosa Ravioli”: The Best Homemade Pasta on Long Island

Next up is none other than “La Gustosa Ravioli”, which was voted as the Best Homemade Pasta on Long Island multiple times – an honor that is not bestowed lightly. Their accolades testify to their consistent excellence over the years!

 

best pasta long island

Savoring the Four-Course Italian Meal at 18 Bay Restaurant

Situated within Shelter Island House Hotel is 18 Bay Restaurant. Here you can savor a four-course meal featuring authentic pastas that will transport you straight to the heart of Italy. This place exhibits how food transcends borders and brings cultures together.

Unfolding the Impressive Pasta Offerings at Cafe Baci

Cafe Baci is described as one of the best Italian restaurants not only on Long Island but possibly even in New York. In all our posts, we’ve rarely come across a menu as impressive and diverse as theirs, especially when it comes to pasta varieties.

The Crowd Favorites: al di la Trattoria, Lilia, Maialino

When it comes to popular crowd favorites, al di la Trattoria, Lilia and Maialino (vicino) need no introduction. They were among mentioned favorites across multiple lists – a testament to their consistent quality and beloved status among customers.

The Japanese-Italian Fusion Experience at Basta

Basta, by the way, offers something slightly different yet equally exciting. Featuring innovative fusions between Italian and Japanese cuisine from their creative menu, this place turns dining into an experience you will never forget!

In conclusion, there is no shortage of options when it comes to excellent pasta on Long Island! Whether eating out or seeking homemade pasta to cook at home – you will find a place that suits your taste among these recommended spots.

best pasta long island

 

 

My Personal Take about Best Pasta Long Island

Hey there my friend, let me tell you a mouthwatering tale about the best pasta in Long Island. You see, being an expert in all things travel in this East Coast paradise, I’ve had the pleasure of savoring some of the most delicious pasta dishes that Long Island has to offer.

Long Island isn’t just about beautiful beaches and summertime wine tours, it’s also a gastronomic haven for foodies like us! The first stop on our culinary journey would be ‘Trattoria Diane their spinach and ricotta gnocchi is stuff that dreams are made of!

Then we have Cafe Testarossa where the paccheri with braised short ribs will leave you craving for more. Another hidden gem is ‘Tellers Chophouse their lobster mac ‘n’ cheese takes comfort food to a whole new level.

And that my friend is just the tip of iceberg when it comes to finding the best pasta Long Island. There are still so many restaurants waiting to be discovered. This beautiful island marries traditional Italian flavors with modern culinary techniques, resulting in some unique pasta dishes that you won’t find anywhere else.

So if your taste buds are yearning for some authentic Italian delight or if your heart desires a serene getaway featuring luscious vineyards, pristine beaches and historical sites… let Long Island be on top of your travel list!

It’s a place where you can discover, enjoy and take in the best of what life has to offer. Fall in love with Long Island, one pasta dish at a time. And who knows, you might even find your own favorite that hasn’t made it to my list yet! And that’s the beauty of this gastronomic adventure – there’s always something new to be discovered.

Let this incite not just your appetite but also your desire to explore and experience Long Island. Until then, keep dreaming about that perfect plate of pasta!

 

Frequently Asked Questions about Best Pasta Long Island

Best for Hotels
Hilton Honors

The Hilton Honors program has teamed up with Points to offer its members a chance to purchase Honors points, whether they require more to secure a luxurious hotel room or are simply hoarding them for future adventures.

To sweeten the deal, frequent bonus and discount offers are regularly extended to encourage members to take the plunge and buy points.

With Points.com at the helm, the most prestigious loyalty brands in the world are able to connect with their members in innovative ways, both on the Points.com platform and through their own loyalty program websites.

We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

Before you go…

Whether you’re visiting Long Island for the first time or you’re a local, there’s always something new to discover here. For food lovers, particularly those with a fondness for Italian cuisine, you have quite the treat in store for you. Long Island is known far and wide for its ability to serve up some of the best pasta you’ll ever taste.

Now that your visit is taking an Italian turn, why not dive further into Italy’s culinary traditions by visiting our recommended Italian bakeries on Long Island? Treat yourself to a variety of scrumptious breads, pastries and cookies after indulging in pasta. And while we’re on the topic of food, let’s not disregard all other global cuisines present here. If gluten-free dining is important to you or someone in your group, then exploring our guide to the best gluten-free pizzas on Long Island will indeed be enlightening! These pizza joints offer all the flavorsome fun minus any gluten-related concerns.

 

Sharing is caring!

George from We Like Long Island

We Like Long Island is a vibrant online community dedicated to celebrating the beauty, culture, and charm of Long Island, New York. Our passionate team of writers and contributors are deeply rooted in the local scene, providing readers with insightful articles, event updates, and hidden gems across the island. From stunning beaches and lush parks to mouthwatering culinary experiences and thriving arts scenes, We Like Long Island aims to showcase the very best of this unique region. Join us as we explore and share the stories that make Long Island a truly exceptional place to live and visit.

Keep Reading