Best Long Island Lobster Roll: A Must-Try Delicacy for Seafood Lovers

By George from We Like Long Island •  Updated: 08/06/23 •  9 min read

Sharing is caring!

best lobster roll long island If you’re a bonafide lover of all things seafood, and the idea of biting into a mouth-watering lobster roll makes your heart skip a beat, then buckle up. I’m about to take you on a culinary journey unlike any other. All of our posts are devoted to unearthing delicious gems from regional cuisines around the world, but today we’re setting our sails for a little island that’s big on taste.

Yes folks, we’re talking about Long Island – the mecca for fresh seafood. Sit back and picture this; beachside dining at an unassuming lobster shack with wafts of the ocean breeze mingling with the alluring aroma of cooking seafood. Now imagine taking that first savory bite of what many call the best Long Island lobster roll. It’s popular for good reason – overflowing with succulent lobster meat nestled within a perfectly toasted bun – it is an authentic taste sensation that truly captures the essence of local cuisine.

Whether you’re already a fan or simply curious to dip your toes in these flavorful waters, journeying through this top-rated eatery landscape promises an unforgettable adventure. Beneath those quintessential striped umbrellas and twinkling fairy lights lies more than just fantastic fare; it’s here where traditions have been upheld by local families providing not just meals but memories. So pull up a chair (virtual or otherwise), as we embark on this delicious escapade exploring where to find that elusive blend – freshest ingredients, authentic recipes and most importantly – love! Because isn’t that what makes any dish truly great? Stay tuned as I share my quest in finding the best Long Island Lobster Roll – it’s surely going to be one tasty ride!

best lobster roll long island

Exploring the Long Island Lobster Roll Scene

The best Long Island lobster roll is a culinary treasure that brings joy to seafood lovers. An alluring blend of simple ingredients, each bite delivers the authentic taste of fresh seafood sourced from local waters. The delectable treat has gained such popularity among residents and tourists alike, that it’s become an integral part of the local cuisine.

Each mouth-watering lobster roll served on this iconic island has its own unique flair. Whether it’s a classic recipe served in a beachside dining setting or a new twist on an old favorite at a top-rated eatery, you can’t go wrong. It doesn’t matter if you’re dining at an upscale restaurant or grabbing a quick bite from a bustling lobster shack – every establishment on the island competes for the title of “Best Long Island lobster roll.”

Join us as we embark on this flavorful journey across Long Island to explore some highly rated spots doling out the most delicious lobsters rolls.

Tasting the Best at DJ’s Clam Shack

DJ’s Clam Shack is renowned amongst locals and tourists alike for serving up the best long island lobster roll. Bursting with chunks of succulent lobster meat tossed in light mayo and served in a buttery bun, it’s no wonder this place keeps making headlines.

Apart from their signature dish, DJ’s is revered for its friendly atmosphere and excellent service. The shack provides both indoor dining and outdoor seating options – perfect for those looking to enjoy their meal whilst soaking up some sun.

Apart from being popular among patrons for its delicious food, DJ’s has made waves across online food forums where rave reviews laud them as one of the must-try spots on your culinary exploration.

Discovering Shinnecock Lobster Factory’s Signature Dish

 

If there’s one thing that sets Shinnecock Lobster Factory apart, it’s their commitment to serving only fresh seafood. This dedication reflects in each dish they serve but nowhere more so than in their famous lobster roll.

Their lobster rolls are generously filled with plump pieces of flavorful crustacean enveloped within perfectly toasted buns slathered with rich creamy butter – truly capturing an authentic taste that is uniquely ‘Shinnecock.’

This top-rated eatery not only offers delectable food but also boasts beautiful scenic views that make your dining experience even better. It’s no wonder Shinnecock Lobster Factory often features highly among ‘best long island lobster roll’ lists!

The Lobster Shack: A Seafood Lover’s Dream

 

The Lobster Shack serves up some stellar versions of our beloved delicacy – making it nothing short of dreamland for seafood lovers! Their scrumptious offering carries large chunks of juicy Maine lobsters lightly tossed in mayonnaise ensconced between warm bread rolls – mouth-wateringly good!

Apart from serving amazing food, they also cater to various dietary preferences by providing gluten-free options – ensuring nobody misses out on sampling their exquisite dishes.



For seafood lovers who crave variety alongside taste– rest assured – at The Lobster Shack there exists more than just what meets the eye! They also whip up other sumptuous seafood delights like steamers and fish sandwiches complemented by sides that amplify flavors adding more depth to your palate.

Lobster Roll Main St., Amagansett:Savoring the Flavors


Any conversation about ‘the best long island lobster roll’ can’t conclude without mentioning ‘Lobster Roll Main St., Amagansett.’ Also known as ‘Lunch,’ this quintessential beachside restaurant nestled along one side offers mesmerizing water views enhancing your dine-out experience.

The restaurant masters classic recipes delivering consistently good quality artfully balancing taste & presentation without compromising freshness or flavor!


Their lip-smacking version includes copious amounts of succulent lobsters adorned atop warm crisp rolls served with coleslaw & fries; enough reasons why they deservedly rank high amongst favorites.
Lobster Roll Sound Ave., Riverhead: Experiencing Unique Twists


Welcome to ‘Lobsters Rolls Sound Ave.,’ located within scenic Riverhead! This place serves not just any ordinary dish but adds unique twists sure to leave your tastebuds dancing!


Their delish version consists large tender pieces kissed with light mayo accompanied by celery bits tucked into soft warm toasties – something you definitely want coming back!


Their commitment towards sourcing quality ingredients promising unmatched freshness coupled charming ambience makes them worthy contender when considering where get best long island lobster rolls. End

My Perspective about Best Long Island Lobster Roll

Hello there, my friend! I’m George, your go-to expert for everything travel-related in Long Island. Recently, I’ve been on a culinary adventure to find the best Long Island lobster roll. What’s more enjoyable than indulging in an exquisitely prepared seafood delicacy while soaking up the stunning views of our beautiful island?

After countless tastings and delightful conversations with local chefs, I found what, in my opinion, is the best lobster roll on Long Island – and believe me when I say it’s an absolute must-try for seafood lovers! Whether you’re a native or a visitor planning your trip to our fantastic piece of paradise, don’t miss out on this heavenly treat. It’s a testament to the rich culinary heritage we’re upholding here in Long Island. And remember, there’s always something enticing waiting to be discovered around every corner on this beautiful island of ours. So why not start with our delicious lobster roll? Welcome to Long Island – where delectable food meets unforgettable experiences!

 

Best for Hotels
Hilton Honors

The Hilton Honors program has teamed up with Points to offer its members a chance to purchase Honors points, whether they require more to secure a luxurious hotel room or are simply hoarding them for future adventures.

To sweeten the deal, frequent bonus and discount offers are regularly extended to encourage members to take the plunge and buy points.

With Points.com at the helm, the most prestigious loyalty brands in the world are able to connect with their members in innovative ways, both on the Points.com platform and through their own loyalty program websites.

We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

Sharing is caring!

George from We Like Long Island

We Like Long Island is a vibrant online community dedicated to celebrating the beauty, culture, and charm of Long Island, New York. Our passionate team of writers and contributors are deeply rooted in the local scene, providing readers with insightful articles, event updates, and hidden gems across the island. From stunning beaches and lush parks to mouthwatering culinary experiences and thriving arts scenes, We Like Long Island aims to showcase the very best of this unique region. Join us as we explore and share the stories that make Long Island a truly exceptional place to live and visit.

Keep Reading