Best Antique Stores on Long Island: A Treasure Hunter’s Guide

By George from We Like Long Island •  Updated: 10/14/23 •  10 min read

Sharing is caring!

 

If you’re on the quest for the best antique stores on Long Island, this guide is your treasure map.

Start off by exploring the charming collection at Lydia’s Antiques And Stained Glass, ranked amongst the top voted stores, famed for its stunning assortment of stained glass art pieces and antiques that echo tales of bygone eras.

Next, dive into a trove of unique finds at the renowned Oakdale Antiques Plaza, a place where antiquity whispers through every item.

From there, journey onto two venues known for their wide variety –L I Antiques Center and Barntique Village. These places offer an eclectic mix of vintage wares and memorabilia, sure to capture every collector’s attention.

The adventure continues as we venture towards North Fork and other vintage specialized stores decanting historical elegance. Lastly, indulge in eco-friendly shopping at the covetedThe Long Island Antiques Center in Merrick and unearth unique items at Lost & Found Antiques and other prominent locations- home to many hidden gems waiting to be discovered.

best antique stores on long island
Courtesy of @ 

best antique stores on long island

Exploring Lydia’s Antiques And Stained Glass and Other Top Voted Stores

If you share my love for antique hunting on Long Island, the first stop should unquestionably be Lydia’s Antiques And Stained Glass. All things considered, this gem of a store is among the top-rated antique stores on Long Island, beloved by both antique collectors Long Island and casual shoppers alike. Now that I think about it, don’t forget to also check out popular names like Stam Galery, Vinyl Bay 777, and The Antique & Thrift Shop. You see, each of these stores offers a diverse range of antiques from furniture to vintage decor.

Diving Into the Unique Finds at Oakdale Antiques Plaza

In any case, if you’re like me and enjoy diving into pools of unique finds, do consider making a trip to Oakdale Antiques Plaza. This local favorite is renowned as one of the best antique shops Long Island has to offer – its shelves teeming with cool and unique items waiting for you to discover.

best antique stores on long island

Rosie’s Vintage: A Huntington Treasure Trove

The town of Huntington takes pride in Rosie’s Vintage on Woodbury Road; voted as the Best Antique Store by Long Islanders! By the way, their collection truly reflects why they’re considered one of the finest vintage stores Long Island boasts.

Discovering Variety at L I Antiques Center and Barntique Village

All things considered if variety is what tickles your fancy in antique hunting then L I Antiques Center or Barntique Village are must-visits. Their vast collection is a delight for any antique furniture shops Long Island enthusiasts.

North Fork: A Trip Down Memory Lane

In the spirit of relishing our seafaring history, North Fork – a popular destination for Long Island vintage market lovers, offers antiques that paint an exquisite picture of the old seafaring world. Yard Sale Depot and The Vintage Living have also carved their names on the list of top-tier vintage stores Long Island hosts.

best antique stores on long island

Eco-Friendly Shopping at The Long Island Antiques Center in Merrick

If you’re into eco-friendly shopping like I am, you’ll appreciate why the Long Island Antiques Center in Merrick is highly rated by customers. Here, secondhand and antique shops thrive, making it one of the most sought-after vintage markets on Long Island.

Unearthing Unique Items at Lost & Found Antiques and Other Prominent Locations

Lost & Found Antiques in New Hyde Park is a haven for those seeking something specific or special – constantly surprising its visitors with an array of unique items. Ann Madonia Antiques; Vestige Vintage; Alessi Paul; Funk & Swagger; Material Objects; Jamesport Red Barn; Backstreet Antiques; Cobble Cat are other prominent locations not to be missed during your antique hunting trail on Long Island.

Remember to check out thrift stores like Changing Tides Consignment while antiquing on Long Island – you never know what treasures may await you! In conclusion, there’s no shortage when looking for the best antique stores on long island – each store resplendent with its own unique offerings and charm. 

best antique stores on long island

 

 

For those planning on a day out in Long Island, it’s recommended to start your day by treating yourself to a unique breakfast. Consider stopping by one of the best antique stores to discover some hidden treasures before heading out. Enjoy a sumptuous breakfast in one of the many great restaurants the island offers and then head over shop for some great antiques.

After you spend the morning browsing for vintage items, take advantage of sunny Long Island days and go visit one of the best free beaches. With their soft sand and calm waves, these beaches are perfect places to unwind after your antique shopping spree. Don’t forget to pack a picnic with some delicious finds from local delis!

Long Island’s maritime history is closely tied with its love for antiques, as many goods in these shops were once part of ships that sailed these seas centuries ago. Visit our dedicated page on Long Island’s history at sea, where you can learn about the exciting historical connections between Long Island’s seafaring past and its plentiful antique stores. Spending time at maritime museums and sites will add depth to your antiquing experience.

Nothing beats ending a good day with fantastic food; luckily, Long Island boasts an array of popular restaurants that locals swear by. After visiting an antique store or two, why not cap off the day at one of these eateries? Get firsthand recommendations on where to satisfy your appetite in our guide to popular restaurants on Long Island.

My Personal Take about Best antique stores on Long Island.

Hey there, treasure hunter! So you’ve decided to dive into the rich world of antiquing and are interested in exploring the best antique stores on Long Island, eh? Lucky for you, I am George, your trusty guide through everything related to travel and adventure on Long Island. Let me tell you, this place is a goldmine for antique hunters just like yourself! And with my deep knowledge about all things Long Island and my passion for curiosities from the past, we’re going to embark upon an unforgettable journey.

We’ll start off with a trip to the serene town of Roslyn where one can find treasures beyond imagination at its multiple antique stores. From there, we’ll make our way towards East Hampton – a hub that bursts with antiquity in every corner. Finally, let’s not forget Sea Cliff Mini Mart where each vendor offers something unique that whispers tales of a forgotten era. Along the journey

By the end of our trip exploring these best antique stores on Long Island, I’m sure you’ll not only come back with some delightful antiques but also fresh inspirations and stories to tell. Here’s to a wonderful treasure hunting adventure awaiting us – shall we dive in?

 

Frequently Asked Questions about Best antique stores on Long Island.

 

Before you go…

While you’re indulging in the rich heritage at the best antique stores on Long Island, don’t forget to plan a visit to some of its other incredible attractions. If you’re an art enthusiast, make sure you check out the top destinations for art lovers, where you can find masterpieces that will leave you astounded. Admire the intricate works of local and international artists that capture Long Island’s beautiful scenery and vibrant culture.

Antique hunting can be a little draining but also fun, spice up your day by unwinding at one of the best car washes on Long Island. After a long day roaming dusty antique shops, give your vehicle some TLC with professional cleaning services. Who knew seeking out antiques could lead to such an exciting and diverse adventure around Long Island?

 

Sharing is caring!

George from We Like Long Island

We Like Long Island is a vibrant online community dedicated to celebrating the beauty, culture, and charm of Long Island, New York. Our passionate team of writers and contributors are deeply rooted in the local scene, providing readers with insightful articles, event updates, and hidden gems across the island. From stunning beaches and lush parks to mouthwatering culinary experiences and thriving arts scenes, We Like Long Island aims to showcase the very best of this unique region. Join us as we explore and share the stories that make Long Island a truly exceptional place to live and visit.

Keep Reading